Are you a fan of Potbelly sandwiches? If you’ve ever visited a Potbelly Sandwich Shop and wondered if there’s more to the menu than the classic toasted sandwiches, the answer is yes. Potbelly has a “secret menu,” also called the Underground Menu, that adds extra variety and fun to your meal.
Top Potbelly Sandwiches 2025 – The Sandwich Lover’s Must-Try List
Updated Potbelly Breakfast Menu with Prices for 2025
This hidden menu is not difficult to order from—it’s simply a mix of app-exclusive items and popular custom sandwich combinations that regulars love. These special creations give you a chance to try something beyond the standard board and make your meal feel more personalized.
In this guide, we’ll explain how the Potbelly secret menu works, highlight the most popular hidden items, and share simple tips to get the best flavor combinations. Whether you want a bigger, meat-filled sandwich or a lighter choice with a sweet touch, the Underground Menu has something for you. Let’s take a closer look at what makes it worth trying.
Italian Sandwich – A True Taste of Italy
A Wreck® – Potbelly’s Most Loaded Sandwich
The Story Behind Potbelly’s Secret Menu
Potbelly Sandwich Shop started in 1977 inside a small antique store in Chicago’s Lincoln Park. At first, the owners served simple toasted sandwiches on the side, but the idea quickly grew. Today, Potbelly has more than 400 locations across the U.S., known for their fresh-baked bread, quality meats, and warm, toasty sandwiches.
The so-called “secret menu” at Potbelly isn’t hidden anymore. A few years ago, the company introduced the Underground Menu, which is only available through the Potbelly app. This move rewarded loyal customers while keeping that feeling of discovery alive. Many of these special items started as customer or employee creations that became so popular they stuck around. Famous examples include the Elvis-style sweet and savory sandwich and the meat-loaded Lucky 7.
In 2023, Potbelly officially added the Lucky 7 to its Underground Menu, and in 2025, they launched the Barnyard—a hearty mix of their A Wreck sandwich plus bacon and meatballs. These additions show how Potbelly takes customer hacks and turns them into fan favorites. For many fans, downloading the app feels like unlocking hidden flavors. And if you’re in-store, sometimes asking politely at the counter can get you a custom version too. Just keep in mind—not every shop knows every secret item, so try during quieter hours when staff have more time.
What makes Potbelly’s Underground Menu stand out is the same thing that makes their regular menu special—fresh ingredients and customization. The bread is baked in-house, meats are antibiotic-free, and you can always add free toppings like hot peppers, pickles, or extra veggies. If you’re searching for Potbelly secret menu items or Underground Menu sandwiches, you’re really stepping into a world of creative twists that go beyond the classic Turkey or Mediterranean subs.
Potbelly Secret Menu Items
Potbelly’s secret menu is all about unique sandwiches and creative food hacks. These are not listed on the regular menu but are popular with fans who like mixing and matching ingredients. The main highlight is the secret sandwiches—big, flavorful combos made by blending classic items in new ways.
But it’s not just about the sandwiches. Potbelly’s hidden menu also includes sweet treats and lighter choices that many people don’t know about. I’ve tried some of these items and also checked what other fans recommend. Below, you’ll find a clear breakdown of the best secret menu picks, their ingredients, and why people love them. I’ve also added simple tips on how to customize them to your taste.
Keep in mind, these items are unofficial hacks, so what you can order may depend on the location and what ingredients are available.
Epic Meat-Lover Sandwiches
Lucky 7
A giant combo of the Wreck and Italian sandwiches, stacked with seven meats: ham, turkey breast, roast beef, salami, pepperoni, capicola, and mortadella. Finished with provolone, lettuce, tomato, and mayo for a salty, smoky, peppery bite.
Price: ~$9.99 (Big) | Calories: ~1,000–1,500
Fireball
Meatballs mixed with chili, hot peppers, and cheddar cheese, with optional marinara for tang. Spicy yet balanced, with a sweet kick from the peppers.
Price: ~$7.99 (Regular) | Calories: ~800
Wrecking Ball (Barnyard Variation)
The Wreck sandwich loaded with meatballs—and bacon for the Barnyard version. Includes turkey, ham, roast beef, salami, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayo for a true protein-packed bite.
Price: ~$8.49 | Calories: ~1,200+
Sicilian
Italian-style layers of salami, pepperoni, capicola, meatballs, mushrooms, marinara, provolone, and hot peppers. A bold, saucy sub with pizza-like flavors.
Price: ~$8.49 | Calories: ~1,000+
Clubby
Turkey, ham, bacon, provolone, lettuce, tomato, and ranch dressing instead of mayo. Creamy and savory with a balanced bite.
Price: ~$7.99 | Calories: ~850
Lighter or Unique Twists
Cheeseburger
Meatballs without marinara, paired with cheddar, mustard, ketchup, pickles, lettuce, tomato, and mayo. A fun sub-style burger experience.
Price: ~$7.49 | Calories: ~900
Black and Bleu
Roast beef topped with blue cheese crumbles, hot peppers or hot sauce, lettuce, and tomato. Tangy and creamy with bold flavors.
Price: ~$7.99 | Calories: ~950
Elvis
A sweet-and-salty classic made with peanut butter, banana, and bacon on toasted bread.
Price: ~$6.99 | Calories: ~700
TTLT (Toasty Turkey BLT)
A lighter BLT with turkey, lettuce, and tomato on toasted bread. Fresh and simple.
Price: ~$6.50 | Calories: ~600
Desserts & Shakes
Cookie Collision Shake
Vanilla ice cream blended with Oreo crumbles and shortbread cookies, topped with more cookie pieces. Rich and crunchy.
Price: ~$5.00 | Calories: ~700–900
Chocolate Peanut Butter Banana Shake
A creamy shake made with chocolate syrup, peanut butter, and banana in a vanilla base. Nutty and sweet.
Price: ~$5.50 | Calories: ~800–1,000
Ice Cream Sandwich
Vanilla ice cream layered between two cookies, with oatmeal chocolate chip as a favorite option.
Price: ~$4.50 | Calories: ~500–700
Dream Bar Sundae
A heated Dream Bar (oatmeal, nuts, coconut) topped with ice cream and syrup. Gooey and indulgent.
Price: ~$5.50 | Calories: ~850–1,050
How to Order from the Potbelly Secret Menu Like a Pro
Ordering from the Potbelly secret menu is simple once you know how it works. Not every employee may know every hidden item, so a little preparation helps. Here are some easy tips based on my experience:
1. Use the Potbelly App
Download the Potbelly app to unlock exclusive “Underground Menu” items. As a Potbelly Perks member, you can find rotating options like the Lucky 7 or the Barnyard. You also earn rewards, such as a free sandwich after qualifying orders.
2. In-Store Ordering Hack
When ordering in person, either say the secret menu item by name (for example, “Fireball”) or explain it clearly—like asking for The Wreck with meatballs and bacon. Be polite, and staff will usually customize your sandwich the way you want.
3. Sizes and Add-Ons
Potbelly sandwiches come in three sizes: Original ($7–9), Big (add $2–3 for more), and Skinny (lighter, around $6). You can add extras such as avocado or bacon for about $1, while toppings like veggies and hot peppers are free.
4. Best Time to Order
For the freshest bread, go in the morning. If you want to request special customizations, try to avoid peak lunch or dinner hours when the store is busiest.
Pro Tip: Sign up for Potbelly Perks to save money and unlock deals. I’ve often scored buy-one-get-one offers on secret menu sandwiches. You can also check the Potbelly website or app to confirm which secret menu items are available at your location.
FAQs About the Potbelly Secret Menu
Is there really a Potbelly secret menu?
Yes. Potbelly has a hidden or “underground” menu that started as fan hacks. Some of these items are now available through the Potbelly app.
How much do Potbelly secret menu items cost?
Most secret menu sandwiches and specials cost between $7 and $10, but prices may change depending on the size you order and the location.
Can I order secret menu items online?
Yes. You can order through the Potbelly app. If you use delivery apps like DoorDash or Uber Eats, you may need to add notes to request certain customizations.
What is the most popular Potbelly secret menu item?
Many fans recommend the Lucky 7 sandwich if you like meat, or the Fireball sandwich if you enjoy something spicy.
Are there vegetarian or vegan choices on the secret menu?
Options are limited, but you can try a PB&J sandwich without bacon or ask for other simple swaps to make items vegetarian-friendly.
Does every Potbelly location offer the secret menu?
Most locations do, but the easiest way to make sure is by checking the Potbelly app, since not all shops carry every ingredient.
Why the Potbelly Secret Menu Is Worth Trying for Lunch
The Potbelly secret menu isn’t just a list of extra sandwiches—it shows how creative Potbelly fans and the brand itself can be. These hidden items turn an everyday sandwich into something more exciting and flavorful.
If you usually order the same sub, try switching it up with a Lucky 7 for a hearty meat option or the Elvis for a fun twist with peanut butter and banana. Many customers say these choices make lunch at Potbelly more memorable.
You can easily order secret menu items through the Potbelly app or by asking in-store. Searching “Potbelly near me” is the quickest way to find your closest shop and enjoy these special menu hacks.
Do you have a favorite secret menu sandwich? Share it in the comments—we’d love to hear your go-to Potbelly order.
I’ve been a Potbelly fan for years, visiting locations all over the U.S. and trying just about everything on the menu — from their toasted sandwiches to hearty soups, fresh salads, and, of course, those warm cookies.
I created this site to give people a simple, honest guide to Potbelly’s menu, prices, and top picks. Everything here comes from real visits, firsthand experiences, and careful research using reliable sources like in-store menus and the official Potbelly website.
This site isn’t affiliated with Potbelly Corporation — it’s an independent resource made by a fan, for fans (and for anyone curious to try Potbelly for the first time).
Whether you’re grabbing lunch, planning dinner, or just stopping in for a shake, I hope this site helps you find your new favorite order.
- Top Potbelly Sandwiches 2025 – The Sandwich Lover’s Must-Try List - August 20, 2025
- Potbelly Secret Menu (2025) – Hidden Sandwiches & Custom Orders - August 20, 2025
- Updated Potbelly Breakfast Menu with Prices for 2025 - August 20, 2025